navigation

Brand image crisis - how to deal with it?

PR
Brand image crisis - how to deal with it?

In short

  • Czym jest kryzys wizerunkowy?: Kryzys wizerunkowy to moment, w którym opinia o firmie, marce albo osobie publicznej zmienia się gwałtownie na niekorzyść – z powodu błędu, zaniedbania, wycieku informacji albo…
  • Najczęstsze przyczyny kryzysu wizerunkowego: Reputation crises have different sources, but the first response is always similar: confirm the facts, say what the company will do next, and do not conceal what is already known.
  • Jak NIE rozwiązywać kryzysów wizerunkowych: Pierwszym błędem, jaki popełniają marki w kryzysie, jest działanie bez planu.
  • Kryzys wizerunkowy – potraktuj go jak szansę: Pierwszym etapem zarządzania kryzysem powinna być szybka, ale rzetelna analiza sytuacji i przygotowanie planu komunikacji.

A reputation crisis is a situation in which a single event – a mistake, a statement or a company decision – triggers a wave of criticism faster than the company can respond. You will recognise it by a sudden rise in negative mentions, questions from journalists and a drop in customer trust within a short time. What matters is the speed and manner of the response, not the sheer scale of the event.

If the crisis is already ongoing, the first hours decide everything — see how we manage Crisis PR for companies.

What is an image crisis?

A reputation crisis is the moment when opinion of a company, brand or public figure turns sharply for the worse – because of a mistake, negligence, a leak of information or a decision that audiences did not accept. Unlike ordinary criticism, a crisis spreads quickly and involves many groups at once: customers, the media, employees and sometimes investors.

Not every negative opinion is a crisis. A single dissatisfied customer or one critical comment is simply part of the risk of doing business. We speak of a crisis when the story starts to take on a life of its own – it is repeated, commented on by more and more people and newsrooms, and the company loses control over what is being said about it.

How to recognise a reputation crisis – the first signals

The sooner a company notices the warning signs, the more time it has for a calm response. It is worth watching for:

  • a sudden rise in the number of brand mentions within a short time (hours, not days),
  • several independent questions from journalists about the same event,
  • the same accusation recurring under different posts and across different channels,
  • a drop in sales or website traffic that can be linked in time to a specific event,
  • comments from influencers or high-reach accounts that pick up the story.

Get ready for crisis management and stay ahead of the curve.

Don't act alone - we offer immediate support!

The most common causes of a reputation crisis

Reputation crises have different sources, but the first response is always similar: confirm the facts, say what the company will do next, and do not conceal what is already known.

Source of the crisisExampleWhat to do first
Product or service failurea defective batch of goods, a service outage affecting many customers at onceconfirm the scope of the problem, state who is affected and what happens next
Misjudged marketing campaigna controversial advert, a fabricated story on social mediawithdraw or correct the message, explain the intention plainly
Conduct of an employee or the boarda statement to the media, a public disputethe company’s position and, if necessary, personal consequences
Data leakagea breach of customers’ personal datanotification to the data protection authority (UODO), information for the affected individuals
Chance eventan accident, a technical failure, a disasterthe facts and help for those affected; lessons only later

How NOT to handle reputation crises

The first mistake brands make in a crisis is acting without a plan. Groping in the dark, without forethought, usually only makes the problem worse.

  • Brak przyznania się do błędu. Marka, która nie wykazuje skruchy, nie przyjmuje krytyki albo próbuje się nieumiejętnie tłumaczyć, traci zaufanie odbiorców szybciej niż przez samo zdarzenie.
  • Zaprzeczanie faktom. Volkswagen przez kilka dni po tym, jak 18 września 2015 r. amerykańska agencja EPA wydała zawiadomienie o naruszeniu przepisów Clean Air Act (silniki miały emitować nawet do 40 razy więcej zanieczyszczeń niż dopuszczają normy), nie potwierdzał skali problemu. Dopiero 22 września 2015 r. koncern przyznał, że oprogramowanie oszukujące pomiary emisji zamontowano w około 11 mln pojazdów na całym świecie (źródło: NPR, 22.09.2015). Zwłoka w przyznaniu faktów pogłębiła kryzys zaufania do marki na lata.
  • Kasowanie komentarzy i ukrywanie krytyki. Usunięcie niewygodnych wpisów niemal zawsze wychodzi na jaw i dokłada nowy wątek do kryzysu – tym razem o próbie cenzury.
  • Język korporacyjny bez konkretów. Komunikat pełen ogólników („dokładamy wszelkich starań”) bez odpowiedzi na pytanie, co konkretnie się stało i co firma robi, brzmi jak unik.

Who in the company should respond first

In many companies a reputation crisis is made worse not by the event itself but by a lack of clarity over who has the right to speak. When a random person answers journalists’ questions or social media comments – without knowledge of the whole matter and without board approval – the company exposes itself to contradictory versions of the same event. That is why, before any crisis, it is worth establishing who gathers the facts, who approves the wording of statements and who is the only person authorised to speak externally. Usually these are a press spokesperson or someone from the PR team, a board representative and – in legal matters such as a data breach – the legal department.

The legal department should not, however, take over all of the communication. Its task is to check that the company’s position does not expose it to additional legal consequences, but the final wording of the statement must be understandable to an ordinary reader and not written in the language of court documents. A statement that sounds like protection against a lawsuit rather than an honest answer to customers’ questions usually deepens mistrust instead of easing it.

Reputation crisis – treat it as an opportunity

The first stage crisis management powinna być szybka, ale rzetelna analiza sytuacji i przygotowanie planu komunikacji. W sytuacji kryzysowej trzeba działać szybko, lecz racjonalnie – nie można dać się ponieść emocjom.

  1. Potwierdź fakty i zbierz zespół decyzyjny. Zanim ktokolwiek publicznie się wypowie, musisz wiedzieć, co naprawdę się stało.
  2. Ustal jedno źródło komunikatów. Kilka różnych wersji od różnych osób w firmie to prosta droga do kolejnego kryzysu.
  3. Przygotuj stanowisko z konkretami. Kto, co, kiedy i co firma robi dalej – bez ogólników.
  4. Wybierz kanał odpowiedni do skali problemu. Kryzys w mediach społecznościowych wymaga innego tempa niż kryzys, o który pytają dziennikarze.
  5. Monitoruj reakcje i koryguj przekaz. Pierwsze stanowisko rzadko jest ostatnim – trzeba obserwować, co odbiorcy rozumieją inaczej, niż firma zakładała.

A company in crisis should accept criticism and promise to improve. Recipients are able to forgive even the biggest image mishap when the brand admits its mistake and sincerely apologizes for its behavior.

Checklist: the first 24 hours of a reputation crisis

The first day decides whether the story fades or grows. The checklist below sets out the order of action once the signs of a crisis have been confirmed.

TimeAction
Hour 0–1Confirm the facts internally, convene the decision-making team
Hour 1–3Agree a single version of events and the person authorised to speak
Hour 3–6First short statement in the channel where the story appeared
Hour 6–24Fuller explanation, answers to media questions, monitoring of reactions
After 24 hoursAssess whether a second wave of communication is needed or the story is dying down

Examples of reputation crises worth learning from

Specific cases reported in the media show better than general principles what works and what makes the problem worse.

  • KFC w Wielkiej Brytanii (luty 2018). Po zmianie firmy logistycznej ponad połowa z około 900 restauracji KFC w Wielkiej Brytanii została czasowo zamknięta z powodu braku kurczaka – w poniedziałek działało tylko około 325 lokali (źródło: Euronews, 20.02.2018). Sieć nie ukrywała problemu, tłumaczyła jego przyczynę i kilka dni później opublikowała żartobliwe przeprosiny w prasie, odwracając litery w swoim logo. Połączenie szybkiego wyjaśnienia z samokrytycznym humorem złagodziło falę krytyki.
  • LPP / Reserved, kampania „Polski Chłopak” (marzec 2017). Marka Reserved opublikowała na YouTube spreparowany filmik – rzekomą historię dziewczyny szukającej poznanego na koncercie warszawskiego chłopaka. Nagranie obejrzało blisko 2,2 mln osób, ale gdy internauci zorientowali się, że historia jest fikcyjną reklamą, pojawiły się zarzuty manipulacji i wezwania do bojkotu (źródło: StrefaInwestorow.pl, 23.03.2017). To przykład kryzysu wywołanego nie błędem produktowym, a stratą zaufania do samego przekazu marki.
  • Volkswagen, „dieselgate” (wrzesień 2015). Opisany wyżej przypadek pokazuje, jak kosztowne bywa zaprzeczanie faktom zamiast szybkiego ich potwierdzenia.
  • Samsung, wycofanie Galaxy Note7 (wrzesień 2016). Amerykańska agencja CPSC ogłosiła 15 września 2016 r. recall około miliona egzemplarzy telefonu Galaxy Note7 sprzedanych w USA – powodem było przegrzewanie się baterii litowo-jonowej, które doprowadziło do 92 zgłoszonych przypadków w USA, w tym 26 poparzeń i 55 przypadków uszkodzenia mienia, w tym pożarów (źródło: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 15.09.2016). Mimo ogromnych kosztów – kilka tygodni później Samsung całkowicie wstrzymał produkcję modelu – firma zdecydowała się na jawny, szybki recall zamiast prób zminimalizowania problemu, co ograniczyło długofalowe szkody dla marki.

How long does a reputation crisis last, and when is it over?

There is no single answer to how long a reputation crisis lasts – it depends on the scale of the event, the industry and how quickly the company responded. A crisis triggered by one unfortunate post can die down within days if the company addresses it swiftly and specifically. A crisis stemming from a loss of trust in the entire brand – as in Volkswagen’s case – can weigh on a company’s reputation for years, even after the legal matter has been formally closed. Instead of counting days, it is worth watching for concrete signals: whether the number of negative mentions returns to its pre-event level, whether journalists have stopped asking about the story, and whether sales or website traffic have returned to their earlier level.

How to measure the impact of a reputation crisis

Simply counting publications about the crisis says little about its real effects. The AMEC industry standard (the international association for communication measurement) recommends looking separately at how much coverage was produced, what its tone was, how audiences reacted (site visits, enquiries, change of opinion) and whether this translated into a business result. Converting publications into so-called advertising value equivalency, that is, the cost an advert of the same size would have had, is an outdated indicator – the AMEC standard rejects it because it says nothing about the effectiveness of activities. Growth in sales or traffic should also be checked against the period before the crisis, rather than treating mere coincidence in time as proof of impact. It is also worth remembering that a single good month after a crisis does not yet mean trust has been fully rebuilt – longer observation is needed, ideally compared with a similar period before the event.

How Commplace helps in a reputation crisis

Kryzys wizerunkowy nie musi oznaczać końca marki. Z każdego trzeba wyciągnąć wnioski, dzięki którym można zminimalizować ryzyko podobnej sytuacji w przyszłości. Commplace przygotowuje firmy na kryzys, zanim ten się pojawi – przez plan działania, przypisane role i gotowe wzory komunikatów – a w trakcie kryzysu prowadzi komunikację z mediami i odbiorcami. Zobacz, jak działa nasze crisis management.

It is also worth reading: jak wygląda zarządzanie kryzysem krok po kroku, effective communication in a crisis situation and why a crisis situation can happen to any company. Wyniki działań w kryzysie – publikacje, wejścia na stronę, zapytania od klientów – Commplace zbiera w kokpicie Commwork®AI, Next to the team's tasks and deadlines.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How does a reputation crisis differ from ordinary criticism?

Ordinary criticism consists of isolated negative opinions that do not affect how the brand is perceived as a whole. A reputation crisis spreads quickly, involves many groups at once – customers, the media, sometimes investors – and the company loses control over it if it does not respond quickly enough.

What are the first signs of a reputation crisis?

A sudden rise in the number of brand mentions within a short time, several independent questions from journalists about the same event, a recurring accusation across different channels, and a drop in sales or website traffic linked in time to a specific event.

What is the most common mistake in responding to a reputation crisis?

Acting without a plan and failing to admit a mistake. A brand that denies the facts or explains itself without specifics loses audience trust faster than the event that triggered the crisis would have cost it.

Can every reputation crisis be contained?

Not every one can be fully contained, but a swift, honest response with specifics always limits the damage more than silence or denial of the facts – as both good and bad examples from the market show.

Is it worth measuring the impact of a reputation crisis with advertising value equivalency?

No. Advertising value equivalency is an outdated indicator that the AMEC communication measurement standard does not recommend, because it says nothing about real impact on the business. It is better to set a specific goal – for example the number of enquiries – and compare it with the period before the crisis.

Who in the company should be responsible for crisis communication?

One person designated in advance, or a small decision-making team, who gathers the facts and issues a single consistent position. Several different versions from different people in the company usually deepen a crisis instead of putting it out.

Sources: NPR, „11 Million Cars Worldwide Have Emissions 'Defeat Device,’ Volkswagen Says”, 22.09.2015; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, zawiadomienie o naruszeniu Clean Air Act wobec Volkswagena, 18.09.2015; Euronews, „Chicken shortage forces KFC to close over half its UK restaurants”, 20.02.2018; StrefaInwestorow.pl, „LPP zalicza kryzys w Social Media: internauci krytycznie ocenili nową kampanię marketingową Reserved”, 23.03.2017; U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, „Samsung Recalls Galaxy Note7 Smartphones”, 15.09.2016.

Call me Customer panel Contact